i vote for the sampler plate @ Scalo.(for future such dessert outings)
It's cheesecake, gelato & tiramisu.
Sit in the bar and order coffee (w/kahlua or tia maria, or Irish-style, if you're so inclined...they can do it all) and savor it.
Plus, they have live music most nights of the week.
It's my n'hood destination for an after dinner sweet fix.
One of my favorite dessert places is Nick and Jimmy's. Bread Pudding, Coconut Cream Pie and Creme Brule, tiramasu is a family recipe. Wait staff will tell you which desserts are the freshest. Had bread pudding and tira with an irish coffee last Saturday and went to sleep smiling! Yum!
Wow, Thanks for all of your suggestions! Can't wait to try them all out! Yum!